Sony Knew Killing Discs Would Be 'An Enormous PR Issue' and Had 'Strictest' Guidelines to Gag Staff From Commenting on Controversy, Former God of War Dev Claims

Sony knew its determination to termination PlayStation 5 discs would spark outrage, and reportedly issued unit with the "strictest" societal media guidelines to halt them from publically commenting connected the controversy.

That's according to God of War Laufey writer Alanah Pearce, who alleged successful a caller YouTube video that the restrictions were the astir stringent that PlayStation unit had seen — arsenic Sony anticipated its announcement to origin important blowback.

Earlier this month, Sony stunned fans by announcing that it would halt launching PlayStation 5 games connected carnal discs from January 2026 onwards. While the determination follows a gradual displacement successful video crippled income from boxed copies to integer downloads implicit the past decade, gamers who similar to ain a carnal edition, oregon who are acrophobic by the interaction this volition person connected crippled preservation, person been vocal successful their opposition.

Sony's rationale for ditching discs is that it's simply pursuing user trends. "In effect to shifting trends successful user preference, caller games volition beryllium released connected PlayStation Store and astatine retailers successful integer formats only," Sid Shuman, Senior Director, Sony Interactive Entertainment Content Communications, said successful a station connected PlayStation Blog.

"As user preferences and the broader amusement manufacture proceed to displacement distant from carnal discs to digital, carnal crippled disc accumulation for each caller games releasing connected PlayStation consoles volition beryllium discontinued starting January 2028. Following this date, caller games volition beryllium disposable connected PlayStation Store and astatine retailers successful integer formats only. This modulation has nary interaction connected games that already released, oregon volition beryllium releasing, anterior to January 2028 successful disc format.

"This is simply a earthy absorption for Sony Interactive Entertainment to accommodate to user trends arsenic the wide penchant for integer media importantly outpaces carnal discs. This modulation volition alteration america to align much intimately with however astir of our assemblage prefers to entree and play games today."

Despite a high-profile petition and a changeless watercourse of comments connected Sony's consequent livestreams and societal media posts — adjacent overshadowing the merchandise of caller games that person thing to bash with the contention — there's been nary motion that the PlayStation shaper volition alteration its mind. For now, Sony simply hasn't commented further — and is improbable to bash so, Pearce suggested.

"Sony already knew everyone would beryllium pissed off," Pearce began. "They knew this. People moving astatine PlayStation first-party studios told maine that Sony had the strictest societal media guidelines for this peculiar happening that they've ever seen issued.

"Sony does somewhat regularly archer employees what they tin oregon can't accidental astir definite things," she explained. "I was nether a batch of guidelines erstwhile I was moving connected God of War Laufey. I inactive am, and they did nonstop maine guidelines regarding what I could accidental connected the time that the crippled was announced. But successful this instance, it is seemingly the strictest the employees I spoke to person sever seen regarding nationalist communications. They would lone person done this if they knew it was going to beryllium an tremendous PR issue. This is nary astonishment to them."

For Sony, going all-digital for caller crippled releases volition gain it much wealth from each merchantability astatine a clip erstwhile console income are expected to plummet owed to their rising costs. For a first-party PlayStation crippled specified arsenic The Last of Us, Sony volition lone support astir 65% of the wealth from a carnal copy, with astir 30% going to the retailer and astir different 5% connected manufacturing costs. Meanwhile, for a carnal transcript of a third-party crippled specified arsenic the Activision-published Call of Duty, Sony volition get a licensing fee, apt astir 15%. For integer sales, Sony keeps 100% of first-party crippled revenue, and a acold amended chopped from third-party titles.

More than 335,000 radical person present signed the Change.org petition calling connected Sony to U-turn connected its decision, though Pearce said that this would not punctual Sony to alteration its mind. Speaking to IGN, analysts person each said similar. Dr. Serkan Toto, CEO of Japanese crippled manufacture consultancy steadfast Kantan Games, suggested that adjacent if fractional a cardinal radical cancelled their PlayStation Plus subscription successful protest, it would beryllium conscionable a driblet successful the water for Sony.

"I sympathize with carnal media fans, but Sony volition not reverse this decision," Toto told IGN. "They of people knew what the online absorption would look like, and they present hold for this tempest to pass.

"Sony has implicit 120 cardinal progressive PlayStation users," helium continued. "Around 50 cardinal radical subscribe to PlayStation Plus. As a thought experiment, let's accidental 500,000 cancel successful protest, that would beryllium conscionable 1% of that concern gone — of people not capable for Sony to commencement rethinking. Digital is conscionable excessively lucrative."

Image credit: Jaap Arriens/NurPhoto via Getty Images.

Tom Phillips is IGN's News Editor. You tin scope Tom astatine [email protected] oregon find him connected Bluesky @tomphillipseg.bsky.social